It can be either one
These are my thoughts which must be done explicitly. windows is a nightmare to use as a server.
1. Your path to mogrify should be
c:/ImageMagick/mogrify.exe
2. Your data and uploads directories should be set to READ WRITE EXECUTE for EVERYONE and IWAM and IUSER accounts.
3. If the following 2 do not work you can take it one step further and this line in image-inc.php change accordingly to say NT.
Code:
Content visible to verified customers only.
Your having permissions issues.