Ah, I see. You said "...otherwise you must click a link on the left to show something", so I didn't realize I must enable the additional info prompt. Now that it's enabled, I do see the extra profile fields being displayed in the Profile.
I still don't see reviews for registered users though. Just when viewing admin's reviews, and then reviews from all users appear (with HTML). And in the Statistics page, there is a link to Forum Profile, but we don't have the built-in Forum enabled. It seems to point to the regular user Profile though.