Again does it work if you turn off all vb3 integration? This would tell you whether there is a vb3 issue of interference.
Point being here is I can not tell you anything cause it does not appear to be an issue with our code. If you view the source of your page the html is definately being printed. So if the html is printed in the source why is it not showing. If I view many other sites using reviewpost in IE the pros and cons show so this is localized to your install. With that knowledge we need to go through and find out what is blocking it from showing especially since the html is truly in the page source.
Code:
Content visible to verified customers only.